Our Properties

Plum Bottom Creek Properties

Our Plum Bottom Creek Properties consist of two very unique commercial and residential sites. We have (2) commercial offices or retail spaces, (2) one bedroom, and (1) three bedroom apartment available. 


1st floor front retail or office space. Approx 900 Sq Ft., (2) rooms plus storage area. Great location in the center of the Village of Lancaster. This location would be great for an office or small retail store. Be right in the center of the action and enjoy all the activities that happen at your door step on historic West Main Street.


Two Bedroom - Beautiful Historical Apartment for rent on the 3rd floor overlooking the village. 2,200 Sq Ft Apartment with two bedrooms and a large bonus room with wet bar for entertaining. 5 West Main Street was built Ca. 1880 and is located in the Central Ave Historic District in the Village of Lancaster, NY. This apartment hosts the original hardwood floors, it has (2) fireplaces (inactive) and renovated kitchen and bathroom. Floor to ceiling historic wooden windows. (Includes window coverings) In apartment laundry (not in the basement). The apartment overlooks the decorated blue water tower of Lancaster. 


Historic 5 West Main Street
Lancaster, NY 14086

Phone: 716-288-8797 

Property Details:

  • (2) Commercial rentals
  • (2) Two bedroom residential
  • Rates starting at $1000 and up

Photo Gallery